Although Bob Seger originally did this song... Metallica does a much better cover. Bob Seger like talks throughout the whole time and you hear a giggle saxophone or something in the bwackground. Blah.
This version is pretty good, but it's not better. It's simply... different... Segar sings it the way he does because he is going for a more tired, worn-out sounding style. Whereas James sings it with his usual, gravelly voice, which gives it an angry, "i'm sick of this" feel. You're right that it is a saxophone in the background (your misspelling of the word "background" made me giggle a little, by the way), however, the saxophone helps set the mood for the song. replacing it with guitar chords just doesn't generate the same feel.
This version is pretty good, but it's not better. It's simply... different... Segar sings it the way he does because he is going for a more tired, worn-out sounding style. Whereas James sings it with his usual, gravelly voice, which gives it an angry, "i'm sick of this" feel. You're right that it is a saxophone in the background (your misspelling of the word "background" made me giggle a little, by the way), however, the saxophone helps set the mood for the song. replacing it with guitar chords just doesn't generate the same feel.
Although Bob Seger originally did this song... Metallica does a much better cover. Bob Seger like talks throughout the whole time and you hear a giggle saxophone or something in the bwackground. Blah.
When Metallica does it, this song is Rockin'!
This version is pretty good, but it's not better. It's simply... different... Segar sings it the way he does because he is going for a more tired, worn-out sounding style. Whereas James sings it with his usual, gravelly voice, which gives it an angry, "i'm sick of this" feel. You're right that it is a saxophone in the background (your misspelling of the word "background" made me giggle a little, by the way), however, the saxophone helps set the mood for the song. replacing it with guitar chords just doesn't generate the same feel.
This version is pretty good, but it's not better. It's simply... different... Segar sings it the way he does because he is going for a more tired, worn-out sounding style. Whereas James sings it with his usual, gravelly voice, which gives it an angry, "i'm sick of this" feel. You're right that it is a saxophone in the background (your misspelling of the word "background" made me giggle a little, by the way), however, the saxophone helps set the mood for the song. replacing it with guitar chords just doesn't generate the same feel.