Lyric discussion by centobite 

Cover art for I Love The Night lyrics by Blue Öyster Cult

Actually, I also think that mingoesbueno is correct, but Blue Oyster Cult is known for writing songs of supernatural types. I think this song tells a vampire love story. "no mortal was meant to know such wonders" and also "one look in the mirror told me so", vampires do not see their reflections. Also, "I couldn't look away" he was mesmerized by her, a vampiric-type power. Also, the song tells of them only being able to be together during the night time.