Lyric discussion by typo 

Cover art for Song Against Sex lyrics by Neutral Milk Hotel

this one's fun to memorize and sing along to.

Maybe I'm going a little shallow but:

And the first one tore a picture Of a dead and hanging man

(Like someone before, a reference to a "Judah" like man.) (decption/betrayal)

Who was kissing foreign fishes That flew right out from his hands

("Judah" attempting to entice "other" girls. One night stands, but tonight they're fishes that flew right out from his hands. Seems a party like setting)

And when I put my arms around him I felt the blushing blood run through my cheeks And an eeriness surrounded when his tongue began to speak And...