The Night Will Only Know Lyrics

Lyric discussion by Teagana 

Cover art for The Night Will Only Know lyrics by Garth Brooks

"That night will live forever Their first time to lie together They were finally where desire dared them to go Both belonging to another But longing to be lovers Promising each other that the night will only know"

They're both adults, married to other people, and this is the start of their affair.

"But they would pay for their deceiving For a deadly web was weaving Why they picked that spot that evening Lord, the night will only know"

There's karma and fate here. The spot they picked at random turned out to be significant.

"And they watched her fall in silence To save their own alliance"

They watched the woman be assaulted, probably raped, and did nothing, said nothing, because they didn't want anyone to find out about their affair.

"Abandoned and forsaken Too many pills were taken"

I think she was raped, and died by suicide. I agree with earlier comments that murder in a back alley is not going to look like suicide by pills.

"Bound by their behavior They could have been her savior Now guilt becomes the endless debt they owe But another crime was committed And it's never been admitted Have the guilty been acquitted Lord, the night will only know"

Their bad decision, their sin, through luck or fate or whatever, could have led to something good. They only witnessed the crime because of their affair. They could have saved her, but instead of choosing to help, before or after the crime, they committed another crime. Not a legal one, but a moral one. They kept quiet, and placed their reputations above the other woman's life. They have to live the rest of their lives with that guilt.

[Edit: clarity]

My Interpretation