Milk and Cookies Lyrics

Lyric discussion by joemama6811 

Cover art for Milk and Cookies lyrics by Melanie Martinez

This song is simply about Crybaby poisoning the Big Bad Wolf, who had previously kidnapped Crybaby in Tag, You're It.

"1, 2, Melatonin's coming for you" Crybaby's previous name was supposed to be Melatonin. This could also simply suggest the actual vitamin.

"11, 12, I pull off black so well" could be a reference to people wearing black at funerals.

This could be about a toxic relationship, but that would be a second meaning, very different as to what the music video and lyrics suggest.

Song Meaning