Lyric discussion by KK1987 

Cover art for She Loves You lyrics by Gaslight Anthem, The

This is a love song, but I don't think there are two women. It's him, and he believes he has found his true love (for better/for worse), but Juliet is smoking, not looking out for him our calling for him. She just believes in him/believes in his love. But she doesn't feel the same.

She has never belonged to him. He feels he is Romeo, the most romantic story in the world, but she just doesnt think he's the right one.