I'm pretty sure the "We" in this song is "Christians". Cold War Kids are definitely Christians, and it seems like the song is saying, "Look, we're just regular people. We'll be open and honest with you, we'll talk about whatever. We don't have any secrets. Forget the biases and the preconceptions you have about us just because we're "Christians". We won't get upset if you disagree. We're waiting for you." Though what toomanytrees said about it being about their past lyrics in Robbers & Cowards is also very plausible.
I'm pretty sure the "We" in this song is "Christians". Cold War Kids are definitely Christians, and it seems like the song is saying, "Look, we're just regular people. We'll be open and honest with you, we'll talk about whatever. We don't have any secrets. Forget the biases and the preconceptions you have about us just because we're "Christians". We won't get upset if you disagree. We're waiting for you." Though what toomanytrees said about it being about their past lyrics in Robbers & Cowards is also very plausible.