Lyric discussion by philipkindred 

Cover art for Austere lyrics by Joy Formidable, The

Wow. re:edible14. You were close. Just goes to show me, never discount someone else's song interpretation. Sex with a sailor? --"wtf " I thought, when I first read that comment. And also (noticed at the time) no one voted it up, either. But the more I thought about it . . . whang! it hit me.

The comment was actually perceptive. But more important than that, I am AMAZED by the unsung literary prowess of Ritzy and Rhys.

Okay, either I stumbled onto the meaning of this song or I found some amazing co-incidences on the level of "Dark Side of the Rainbow." You decide, while you keep in mind that Ritzy and Rhys are from Wales and as a result probably well influenced by seafaring, shipbuilding, and naval imagery. 4 points:

  1. Medal. Reverse. ? . . . "Reverse of the Medal" -> "an opposite and usually less favorable aspect of an affair." ALSO is the title of a novel about a Royal Navy ship's captain (I'll name him later) at the time of the Napoleonic Wars. From the highly regarded historical fiction series by Patrick O'Brien.

In this novel, the Captain is set-up (framed) as a scapegoat for many gentlemen who lost money in the Great Stock Exchange Fraud of 1814. (wiki this yourself). As a result, he is pilloried and removed from the Royal Navy. However, his wealthy sidekick (Stephen Maturin) actually BUYS the Captain's former ship, obtains letters of marque, and later RE-INSTATES the Captain to command, though now as a privateer. THIS is the referred-to "reverse of the medal" in which now there is "mischief to turn" and again his "ship to send off."

  1. Barbed Wits and Gowns Ransacking the Town. The "gentlemen" in trial of the Captain as regards the historical fraud event above. Any student of post-Elizabethan history knows the meaning of barbed wits and legal gowns in the oratory alongside Parliament or any public trial of a gentleman.

Later, the Captain is protected at the pillory by his loyal seamen, hence the song's voice assures him he will once again dance and "drown in velvet" with his ladies, a familiar habit for the Captain.

  1. Unfinished. Up to this point I was persuaded but not convinced. Until I realized that the LAST book in the series was only three chapters long, known as the "The Final Unfinished Voyage" of the Captain. It was published in 2004 (just in time for Ritzy or Rhys to read it), and UNFINISHED. Being the "last words," so to speak, of the author, who passed away before the story was done. Leaving the Captain, sadly to many fans, "just an unfinished story now."

  2. Still, I puzzled over the word "Austere." Sure, okay, yes this CAN be the stereotypical adjective applied to many fictional ship's captains, it sort of goes with the job: "given to exacting standards of discipline and self-restraint," "harsh and threatening in manner or appearance."

But why is this used in the song also seemingly as a NAME, a moniker? The Captain's name in the series is Jack. Jack Aubrey. AUstere. AUbrey. Ritzy and Rhys had been coy with everything else so I figure this their clever device of alliteration. So as to not just spoon over the name, in a too-obvious way.

Interesting. Let me know what you think, if you have read the series or at least taken the time to look these things up.

Also briefly note that "Reverse of the Medal" is also the title of some intriguing early 1900's literary porn attributed in part to Oscar Wilde. In which a gentleman attending a musical recital becomes entranced by telepathic messages -- yes, lol -- from a concert pianist. And thus is enticed, I'm guessing now, to "reverse his medallion," i.e. switch his sexual affiliation.

But this doesn't fit the other imagery and I don't sense from their body of songwriting that Ritzy or Rhys think this way.