Lyric discussion by Cuthroatclark 

Cover art for Madelyn lyrics by Wonder Years, The

This song is about somebody in the bands sister. Sounds like she has a addiction problem.

I don't think there's a god; I don't think that there's someone coming to save us And I don't think that's the worst news of the day

these lyrics are telling her a "GOD cant save her but maybe he can help.

Madelyn, are you really afraid of death or do you just say it if it's the right thing to say? "

He is scared she doesnt care if she dies, even if she says otherwise.

Maybe it is about a family member that died way back when and he is trying to relate to her? IDK