Lyric discussion by YourLoversWereLiars 

Cover art for Halloween lyrics by Gaslight Anthem, The

This is a fantastic song, and for anyone who closely follows Brian Fallon, it obviously has personal connection. Considering where his personal life has been/is headed at this moment... he is not in a good place. This song, to me, seems to be hinting at his infidelity... but it also seems to symbolize the realization he no longer loves someone he thought he did.