Lyric discussion by JoeBongard 

Cover art for Carol Ann lyrics by Coheed and Cambria

I believe that the last comment could be right. It sounds legit, but another thought; what if Carol Ann was an occupant in the truck with the driver and this is like a side story to that. idk... just a thought.

@JoeBongard Are you talking about the events of Descension? Because this story would've fallen in line with a Key Entity Extraction in the Ascension album. Remember that the car accident involving Sirus happened after he came out of the Keywork, meaning that it wouldn't make sense for him to experience this death since it hasn't happened yet in the timeline. Unless there is some other car accident that I missed somewhere.

As for why it was removed from the canon songs, it was likely because they didn't want to overplay the car accident themes of the album. I'd also...

@sp4zzy yes I was talking about the events of Descension, and as I have never known Claudio to be as deep as he use to be, he would've named it "Key Entity Extraction" and not just Carol Ann. It is not Sirus that would be having this life or death situation, but seeing as you didn't pay attention when my comment specifically mentioned "truck", I was saying how it was possible the truck that hit Sirus had a passenger in it, and Claudio is know to really love elaborating side stories. This could've been some side story set in the...