In Another Life, When We Were Both Cats Lyrics

Lyric discussion by SchwarzMan 

Cover art for In Another Life, When We Were Both Cats lyrics by Maybeshewill

This song is correctly titled '...In Another Life, When We Were Both Cats...'

It is a reference to the quote from Vanilla Sky, 'I will tell you in another life, when we are both cats' which basically translates to Never.

The change in titles implies though it may seem like never, there in fact was a time (in this case where these two loved each other, and it was not so one sided). However, they might as well be one in the same thing, never and sometime in the past so long ago that nobody cares to remember. The only difference is it brings pain to the only person who does.

Matched with the back and forth at the beginning I think its named quite well.