Clarkson wrote this eerie song four or five years prior to recording it on the My December album.
Clarkson explained on her record label's website about this song concerning someone she grew up with that committed suicide: "I was expressing my anger at how someone could do that. Why would you leave all these people behind feeling guilty and wondering what they could have done to prevent it? I really believe that God puts us through these situations to help others."
Clarkson wrote this eerie song four or five years prior to recording it on the My December album. Clarkson explained on her record label's website about this song concerning someone she grew up with that committed suicide: "I was expressing my anger at how someone could do that. Why would you leave all these people behind feeling guilty and wondering what they could have done to prevent it? I really believe that God puts us through these situations to help others."