Lyric discussion by lilangel27 

Cover art for Call Me, Maybe lyrics by Carly Rae Jepsen

what does that part mean when she says"I threw a wish in the well Don't ask me, I'll never tell I looked to you as it fell And now your in my way I trade my soul for a wish Pennies and dimes for a kiss I wasn't looking for this But now your in my way"?????????????

That's just it--even a 30-year-old lady I know doesn't get it. This song makes no sense. The lyrics say nothing, the music is obnoxious, and altogether this song sucks. That's why I listen to rock.

she is saying she threw a wish (penny ) in the well,she wont say what her wish is or it wont come true, shes saying she looked at him as she made the wish and now hes in her way (as in after the wish it came true and now hes in her path were he wasnt before till she wished for it ) she is saying she only wanted to to chase him a bit but now hes permenatly there on her mind (in her way)

It means, that she is a Puella Magi and traded her soul to Kyuubey for a wish. If you watch the anime, you'll see, that's exactly what happens.