Lyric discussion by Khaoki 

To expound on the death of an atheist idea, I believe it's more about death in general and how atheists and theists view it and how that affects their lives.

"If you croak, I hope you know I'm gonna toss you in the trash You can't really blame us; we're only doing what you asked"

To an atheist once your life ends then that's that. Without life your body is essentially trash, as opposed to many religion's views that your body is a vessel to be treasured or preserved. So, to them, ritualistically preserving a body should be viewed as a waste of time.

"If you have yourself a son, I'm gonna tell your baby boy That Father Time's chock full of lies, so don't jump in just yet"

You come into the world being told you'll live a full life into old age, but that isn't the case for many. This is compounded by many religion's promising an eternal life following your mortal death. So, essentially, you're telling a child to live life to its fullest and to not be shackled to the promises of long and everlasting life since "Father Time's chock full of lies."

"Doubting Thomas deserves much more than we can give If we win the lottery, let's buy an island just for him So when that hurricane tries beating down the door We can make him bat its eye 'til it can't see what's a...

Until we can't see what's ahead"

The atheist (Doubting Thomas) is at death's door so the theist's attempt to convert him, for they think he is a good man and deserves more than they believe he'll get (hell) so they can get him his own island in paradise, provided that they are correct in their beliefs and thus win the afterlife lottery. So, the hurricane is beating on the door (death is knocking) and they attempt to make him blink and make him abandon his beliefs, or lack thereof. But at the end of the day, they can't see what's ahead despite all their assurances in their beliefs.

"Until we can't see what's ahead You can sew me in stitches Curse at the cautious While it lasts Cause soon we'll all forget"

The atheist rejects their attempts. They can attempt to repair him, curse his non-belief, while it lasts because eventually everyone dies and thus forgets their beliefs.

"If we croak, I hope you know it's gonna be in single files Hunting for models that were never worth the while"

The religious die and they believe they'll line up for paradise as they have spent their entire lives striving for something people dream for and desired during life but resisted due to the promise of it being there in paradise for them after death.

"Each one of us caught heat for throwing Jack Frost in July Staring at the sun 'til our eyes were done, we could not see what's a..."

They threw snow balls in the middle of summer, or generating controversy over the impossible. They blinded themselves and attempted to blind others to believe in something they could not see in the first place.

An error occured.