I think the first part of the song is a statement about the belief systems around organized religions. That people just blindly accept ideas without ever really thinking freely about them for themselves. The existence of heaven is something that people believe because that's what they've been taught and they just accept it blindly without ever really thinking about it or questioning it. "Your mind's a machine, it's deadly and dull. It's never been still and it's will has never been free".
The narrator would like to punch a hole in the sky so you can see for yourself that there isn't anything there. There is no heaven...it's just life here on earth and that's it. There's isn't much more to it. "There's so much less to this than you think"
I believe the second part of the song is, as others have said, a replication of a migraine.
Great post! You said almost everything I was going to say. Right on! There was one thing I interpreted differently, though.
Great post! You said almost everything I was going to say. Right on! There was one thing I interpreted differently, though.
"Your spine starts to shine
And you shiver at your soul
A fist so clear and climbing
Punches a hole
In the sky
So you can see
For yourself
If you don't believe me"
"Your spine starts to shine
And you shiver at your soul
A fist so clear and climbing
Punches a hole
In the sky
So you can see
For yourself
If you don't believe me"
I think the "spine starts to shine and you shiver at your soul" line is the dawning of a realization that there's likely no god. The "fist so clear and climbing" is that realization, and to me, I think the "fist" is reason....
I think the "spine starts to shine and you shiver at your soul" line is the dawning of a realization that there's likely no god. The "fist so clear and climbing" is that realization, and to me, I think the "fist" is reason. When you take the time to apply reason to the notion of a god, I think the whole idea crumbles or "punches a hole in the sky". Then the line "so you can see for yourself if you don't believe me" means that we all possess the ability to reason things out, so you don't have to take someone else's word for it. To me, he's saying just think about it for yourself if you don't believe.
I didn't realize that the drone at the end was supposed to be a migraine, but I like that. The first time I listened to it, it gave me a little bit of a headache. I don't know about Jeff's spiritual views, but from all of his music that I've heard, he sounds at least skeptical, if not an atheist. Maybe experiencing such pain made him question the existence of a god.
Having said all of that, what I love about this song (and all of Wilco's music, really) is how it can be interpreted in such personal ways. After reading about the migraines, I think this song is much more narrow in focus than debating the existence of god, but I hear a lot of atheistic themes in his music. I admit this could be because I'm an atheist and my spirituality is very important to me, so I'm hearing it through the filter of my own meaning. But either way, I love that I can read what he meant a song to be about, but then take away my own personal meaning, too. My Morning Jacket is another great band that does this really well.
I think the first part of the song is a statement about the belief systems around organized religions. That people just blindly accept ideas without ever really thinking freely about them for themselves. The existence of heaven is something that people believe because that's what they've been taught and they just accept it blindly without ever really thinking about it or questioning it. "Your mind's a machine, it's deadly and dull. It's never been still and it's will has never been free".
The narrator would like to punch a hole in the sky so you can see for yourself that there isn't anything there. There is no heaven...it's just life here on earth and that's it. There's isn't much more to it. "There's so much less to this than you think"
I believe the second part of the song is, as others have said, a replication of a migraine.
Great post! You said almost everything I was going to say. Right on! There was one thing I interpreted differently, though.
Great post! You said almost everything I was going to say. Right on! There was one thing I interpreted differently, though.
"Your spine starts to shine And you shiver at your soul A fist so clear and climbing Punches a hole In the sky So you can see For yourself If you don't believe me"
"Your spine starts to shine And you shiver at your soul A fist so clear and climbing Punches a hole In the sky So you can see For yourself If you don't believe me"
I think the "spine starts to shine and you shiver at your soul" line is the dawning of a realization that there's likely no god. The "fist so clear and climbing" is that realization, and to me, I think the "fist" is reason....
I think the "spine starts to shine and you shiver at your soul" line is the dawning of a realization that there's likely no god. The "fist so clear and climbing" is that realization, and to me, I think the "fist" is reason. When you take the time to apply reason to the notion of a god, I think the whole idea crumbles or "punches a hole in the sky". Then the line "so you can see for yourself if you don't believe me" means that we all possess the ability to reason things out, so you don't have to take someone else's word for it. To me, he's saying just think about it for yourself if you don't believe.
I didn't realize that the drone at the end was supposed to be a migraine, but I like that. The first time I listened to it, it gave me a little bit of a headache. I don't know about Jeff's spiritual views, but from all of his music that I've heard, he sounds at least skeptical, if not an atheist. Maybe experiencing such pain made him question the existence of a god.
Having said all of that, what I love about this song (and all of Wilco's music, really) is how it can be interpreted in such personal ways. After reading about the migraines, I think this song is much more narrow in focus than debating the existence of god, but I hear a lot of atheistic themes in his music. I admit this could be because I'm an atheist and my spirituality is very important to me, so I'm hearing it through the filter of my own meaning. But either way, I love that I can read what he meant a song to be about, but then take away my own personal meaning, too. My Morning Jacket is another great band that does this really well.