Return the Favor Lyrics

Lyric discussion by Kiston 

Cover art for Return the Favor lyrics by All Time Low

My interpretation of this song is that it's about a girl and guy who are like friends with benefits, but the guy actually started to feel something more than that. He knows the girl doesn't feel that way, so he's struggling with the decision to end it since he knows that it will never be what he wants it to be.

"How do I get away When you're begging me to stay?"

The guy is struggling, but he wants to end it with her. He's having a hard time leaving her though because she's making him feel bad about it. The girl might be arguing him on it, probably trying to guilt him into staying by putting herself down, which makes him say, "What do you need me to say? You're anything but ordinary."

When he's says he's given it all to her, he's talking about his heart and she didn't return the favor.