Where to Now St. Peter? Lyrics

Lyric discussion by OpalEyedEssence 

Cover art for Where to Now St. Peter? lyrics by Elton John

I think it's about someone being executed by lethal injection and slipping off into death. The blue canoe is the gurney. They "took the paddles" because they're killing him, they "paralyzed his arms" because they're strapping him down. The change from day-to-day life in the prison to the silence of the execution chamber (away from the rifle range of the guards) is so sudden.

Also, it seems he's being executed for murder committed with a "sweet young foreign gun," taking something for nothing like that ends with a bad report, a conviction.

This song is on the album Tumbleweed Connection, which is a theme album based on the American "Old West." So, I think it has to be interpreted in that context. For that reason, I don't think its about lethal injection, but, like poetry, it can be interpreted however you want, so go with it.

When Taupin wrote this song, lethal injection didn't exist, the concept was barely even known. "Blue Canoe" was probably LSD. It was suggested at the time that the song was about the assination of Robert Kennedy, the "sweet young foreign gun" being Sirhan Sirhan.