Lyric discussion by breakouttheshotguns 

Cover art for Invented lyrics by Jimmy Eat World

A lot of references to wrestling with religion here, probably emphasizing the tradition more so than anything.

Some old-timer pioneer Who believes with shaken faith

Time has taken a toll on his faith, probably both in God and humanity

A busted homesteader Who believes in virgin grace

I think of the Virgin Mary, who was known for her grace (Hail Mary, full of grace)

I also love the line:

I met you the old-fashioned way

Meeting people in person, not through reliance on computers, cellphones, etc. Beautiful.