I Was Scared and I'm Sorry Lyrics

Lyric discussion by TheUpsides 

Cover art for I Was Scared and I'm Sorry lyrics by Wonder Years, The

BryanMac is right, it's about The Upsides leaking on Christmas Eve (and breaking up with his girlfriend).

http://dailymusicreviews.blogspot.com/2010/01/interview-wonder-years.html

Soupy: "I am a very anxious person. It doesn't take much to get to me and takes very little more to cause me to momentarily break and so, finding out the album leaked on Christmas Eve, right before going to dinner with my nana shook me a little (a lot. A fucking lot). Some things really bothered me."

makes more sense now, I just didn't understand why he would get so upset about that in particular

Cause these guys put their heart and souls in to making the upsides the greatest thing they have ever done. And they wanted to be rewarded for it, not have a bunch of people illegally downloading it. These guys are the most amazing band.