Lyric discussion by SomebodyIUsedToKnow 

I don't think this song is about two guys I think it's about just one guy, that has changed in a relationship. When she says 'according to you' she's refferring to how he is now and when she says 'him' she's refferring to how he was in the past. When the relationship started he was perfect and seemed to really love her but over time his true colors began to show (everything is opposite, as the song says)

"He's into me for everything I'm not": I think she's saying that everything he said he loved her for was apparently a lie.

"Why can't you see me through his eyes it's too bad you're making me decide": Here I think she's saying why he can't see her the way he used to see her. And her 'decision' is between whether or not she's gonna stay with him or not.

I think the song ends with the first lyrics again because it's about the same guy (as I said before). She started out talking about how he is now, then started singing about how he used to be and now at the end she's back to seeing him as he really is now.

Just my interrpretation. Others probably don't see it like this...

Very fresh look on the song but don't you think the lyrics would be something like "I feel like rewinding it" rather than "I don't feel like stopping it"? Although you mentioned your interpretation of "too bad you're making me decide" that would actually be a weird line as well in my opinion.

An error occured.