Lyric discussion by deerMAUS 

i think this song is definitely about rape (and the girl wanting revenge). it goes from both perspectives, and is sometimes a conversation:

(Boy:)I said, hey Girl with one eye: Get your filthy fingers out of my pie (Boy:)I said, hey Girl with one eye: I'll cut your little heart out cause you made me cry

and

(Boy:)I slipped my hand under her skirt I said don't worry, it's not gonna hurt (Girl:)Oh, my reputation's kinda clouded with dirt (Boy:)That's why you sleep with one eye open That's the price you paid

etc. etc.

that made sense

An error occured.