Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis? Lyrics

Lyric discussion by shieldyoureyes 

Cover art for Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis? lyrics by Gaslight Anthem, The

I believe part of the line: "It's a broken Hallelujah and a pain in my fist."

is a reference to the Lawrence Arms song "Quincentuple Your Money": "There's a wounded sense of pride and a pain in my fist."