Lyric discussion by mntecky 

Cover art for Caroline lyrics by Old Crow Medicine Show

On Tennessee Pusher, the second verse is a bit different than what's listed above. Also, the last verse up above is not included on that CD. Here's how the second half of the song is on TP:

We were the gas house gang I'll be Ozzie Smith, you'll be Sarah my wife Til' we got traded away To the Red Clay league somewhere along the Georgia line You be the pitcher and the catcher too I'm the home run king 'fore his muscles grew Gonna knock the cover off this time.

Oh Caroline (Round) Caroline Oh Caroline (Round) Caroline Oh Caroline (Round) Caroline (can't remember how many times this repeats...)