Apollo and the Buffalo and Anna Anna Anna Oh! Lyrics

Lyric discussion by equivalence 

Cover art for Apollo and the Buffalo and Anna Anna Anna Oh! lyrics by Sunset Rubdown

i admittedly need a lot of help/suggestions on this one.

Direct from the Sunset Rubdown website:

The buffalo have given up on the world. And Apollo? Apollo is kissing all the valley girls. We climbed up the cross on the mountain on New Year’s Eve: It was just god, the blizzard, the dream-weaver and me.

My god I miss the way we used to be. Here’s a photograph for you to hold. It’s my picture right before I got old. It’s a picture of a buffalo that we rode into extinction. That was the crime we committed in the night…

Apollo, I heard your sister is...