It's about talking to an atheist. "Hey, don't ever bring me back/To where I used to be/Cause now I feel so fine and I feel so peachy" talks about how no matter how much the person he's talking to believes he's wrong, he doesn't want to go back to where he was before he found Jesus. "Friend, can't you see I'm trying to help you out/But ur mind is stuck on things that leave you adrift with broken wings" talks about the situation of the atheist. All the lead singer wants to do is help him out, because the path he's on now leads him astray.
It's about talking to an atheist. "Hey, don't ever bring me back/To where I used to be/Cause now I feel so fine and I feel so peachy" talks about how no matter how much the person he's talking to believes he's wrong, he doesn't want to go back to where he was before he found Jesus. "Friend, can't you see I'm trying to help you out/But ur mind is stuck on things that leave you adrift with broken wings" talks about the situation of the atheist. All the lead singer wants to do is help him out, because the path he's on now leads him astray.