Lyric discussion by alexxxx 

Cover art for Hush lyrics by Automatic Loveletter

breakingbenjaminfan basically got it

i think though that the guy would prolly be pree upset that shes leaving "you color my eyes red" and is in denial that it is any different. and how things change and how everything dulls over time.

Why would he be upset she's leaving? Yeah he might be upset, but that line isn't how HE feels. She says "you color my eyes red", which means SHE is crying.

She knows it's not working and she wants it done.