I don't think the writer is in love with Amanda at all. I always got the impression that the lines like "when she sings its gold" and "Amanda talks about nothing but she'll make you think its poetry" are supposed to be sarcastic. It seems to me like the girl thinks very highly of herself, but she's just a self absorbed, spoiled teenager who needs to grow up.
The song is probably written out of frustration because the girl won't leave him alone rather than being torn because she's too young but he's in love with her despite all these incredibly annoying and unnattractive qualities she has.
I don't think the writer is in love with Amanda at all. I always got the impression that the lines like "when she sings its gold" and "Amanda talks about nothing but she'll make you think its poetry" are supposed to be sarcastic. It seems to me like the girl thinks very highly of herself, but she's just a self absorbed, spoiled teenager who needs to grow up.
The song is probably written out of frustration because the girl won't leave him alone rather than being torn because she's too young but he's in love with her despite all these incredibly annoying and unnattractive qualities she has.