Lyric discussion by AkashaFaeAngel 

Cover art for My My lyrics by Seven Mary Three

This song means that on the outside, he is indifferent to her psychosomatic cries for help. Underneath his cold exterior, as the phonograph says, he enjoys the attention and doesn't want her to leave. Over all she is trying to get the courage to go as trying to convince him that they should be together has been physcially as well as emotionally, hurting her.