Lyric discussion by dropdeadxbaby 

Cover art for Donner Party of Five lyrics by Drop Dead, Gorgeous

Well, first of all, this whole thing about Saylor Lake is a fictional story that Danny Stillman, the lead singer of the band, created. And according to all the articles I read, the rest of the band got super into the idea and created the whole story line. And its the fans job to use the lyrics, and their website www.worsethanafairytale.com, to figure out the mystery of who the killer is. This website and the songs are like clues. Well, since I have been a dedicated fan for two years, I've analyzed like EVERY song. Haha. And I have this theory that the killer is a vampire. I can't find too much direct refernce to my theory in this one. But it does say "I walked in search for 18 years and died for nothing." So he's dead. It could, however, mean emotionally dead. But I don't know. Check my comments on other songs to see why I have this theory.