Lyric discussion by dropdeadxbaby 

Well, first of all, this whole thing about Saylor Lake is a fictional story that Danny Stillman, the lead singer of the band, created. And according to all the articles I read, the rest of the band got super into the idea and created the whole story line. And its the fans job to use the lyrics, and their website worsethanafairytale.com, to figure out the mystery of who the killer is. This website and the songs are like clues. Well, since I have been a dedicated fan for two years, I've analyzed like EVERY song. Haha. I have this theory that the killer is a vampire.

"They call me Jesse James and I own the night life. I drift from town to town across the nation. Praise the lord, lock and load boys. We go down, we go down, we go down together."

First of all, he owns the night life. Obviously vampires only come out at night. Yes, I understand serial killers usually do too, but if you read my other ideas about this on other songs, then you might understand.

And he's using his new found power to get revenge on all the girls that have done him wrong in his life.

"Go tell this town I've built them all their coffins. As for this face, best it be forgotten. Hells on it's way, no one's gonna stop it. I wear this suit, on one's gonna top me. "

It just seems fishy. But if he is a vampire, then who bit him? Find out my theory by reading my comment on the last song: "I Want to Master Life and Death".

An error occured.