I think he had a crush on her in high school, but she never had feelings back, and now he wants to feel better about being rejected and rapes her.
("He burns her high school pictures. And buries old dreams." "He sews the crack in his heart. Before he tears her apart.")
And, "Never say no to me." she is telling him to stop. And after he has raped her he regrets it. ("He cleans the tears from her eyes. He still can't stand to see her cry.")
I think he had a crush on her in high school, but she never had feelings back, and now he wants to feel better about being rejected and rapes her. ("He burns her high school pictures. And buries old dreams." "He sews the crack in his heart. Before he tears her apart.") And, "Never say no to me." she is telling him to stop. And after he has raped her he regrets it. ("He cleans the tears from her eyes. He still can't stand to see her cry.")