Prey

Well I know this is what the band was shooting for but to me the song is about someone who is pressured into sex and finally has it

"I've been waiting so long for this time I'm terrified Blind in ways I've never realized I don't mind"

All at a time All in the same Califormula I've become prey Strolling down In my face These tears I'm not crying This will not kill me

that may refer to how all at once everything changed and suddenly they realize someone has taken advantage of them

ha this is just what i think when i listen to it