Lyric discussion by mudsown 

Cover art for I'm Not Ready to Forgive You lyrics by Right Away, Great Captain!

I thought about it more, and if the story is in sequence according to the order of tracks on the cd, then my original idea is kind of wrong.

So my new idea is that, maybe after the 3 years at sea, he comes back to his family and finds the new guy. Then he decides to leave back to sea and just spend the rest of his life on the sea.