Lyric discussion by loveisfiction 

Cover art for Vampires In Blue Dresses lyrics by Margot & the Nuclear So and So's

At first, I didn't care for this song and it grew to be one of my favorites.

I think this song has a sarcastic tone to the message.. all because he is telling her "not to give it away", then later he says he should be one of her regrets.. So I think he does want her to give it away, but to him, not anyone else.