Lyric discussion by Nyonben 

Cover art for Why - Part 2 lyrics by Collective Soul

"All my props I swear they were in order Even with the warnings of your thunder Now I pause to let my silence scream tonight Awhile you roam like a serpent satellite "

Everything in his life was fine without her and he KNEW that it would be fine without her, but he's done it again and fallen back in love with her. 'warnings of her thunder'...what's thunder mean? A storm's coming. He knew it would be bad, but he let it happen anyway.

The song's title, no doubt, is a question.

Why have a part 2?

Why, Part 2.?

I have no idea why it's part2. Perhaps its a 2nd version of the same song? Perhaps there is Why part 1 somewhere but just not recorded.