Lyric discussion by schill2002 

Cover art for Lazy Eye lyrics by Silversun Pickups

This song is actually realizing when you're with someone that it is the imperfections that make you love them. Hence the "lazy eye".

100% correct

Hmmmm, but he does say 'with the same ol' decent lazy eye / vexed to rest on you'. I think the 'lazy eye' is referring to his own inability to stay true to the person he's with because he's always looking for something/someone else.

No, im pretty sure, Brian said this in an interview at one point, I don't remember which one thought, so I don't have any documentation