Ed (Charlie's other brother) helped write this, i know cos i asked them personally.
And your right, will did write the majority, oh and Charlie does play it, it's proven when in the live DVD they had to play Why twice because Charlie's guitar was not working and the riff at the start was not playing at all, after two more songs, charlie explained to the audience about the fuck up and played it again, this time the guitar working.
also toward the end, the excat time he hit his foot on the pedal, the reverb turned off.
Ed (Charlie's other brother) helped write this, i know cos i asked them personally.
And your right, will did write the majority, oh and Charlie does play it, it's proven when in the live DVD they had to play Why twice because Charlie's guitar was not working and the riff at the start was not playing at all, after two more songs, charlie explained to the audience about the fuck up and played it again, this time the guitar working.
also toward the end, the excat time he hit his foot on the pedal, the reverb turned off.
Amazing song