Lyric discussion by NightNeverSleeps 

Cover art for Into the Woods lyrics by My Morning Jacket

i was talking to a fellow MMJ fan the other day about the meaning of the first two lines, which always seemed to catch me off-guard:

"A kitten on fire, a baby in a blender. Both sound as sweet as a night of surrender."

it seems so over-the-top, I could never quite wrap my mind around it. here is a theory we came up with by the end of the conversation, however wrong it may be:

He is playing with cultural stereotypes with the shocking imagery (kitten on fire, baby in a blender). Kittens & Babies typically signify innocence and sappy preciousness; they can also represent naivety. The lyrics destruct this innocence in order to represent how, analagously, first love and/or sex (forms of 'surrender' in the metaphor) destroy innocence as well. For instance, think of how idealistic & lofty your interpretation of 'love' was before your first physical relationship. This is what you ultimately 'surrender,' - that blissful ignorance.

The following line "as sweet as a night of surrender" is sarcastic. Of course a kitten on fire or a baby in a blender don't actually sound 'sweet.' He's being ironic. This forfeiting of ones innocence is actually a sad thing, though we don't quite realize until it's gone. At the time though, the action (sex, for instance) seems beautiful, but a part of us is ultimately being destroyed irrevocably.

Hope this makes at least a little bit of sense, but no, I don't put much validity in it. I'm interested to hear what other people think about it.