I agree with everything you just said in addition to that there is also what I figure to be Feanor's justification of returning to middle earth with the host of Noldor in the following lines he is speaking to the Valar - "No sign of life did flicker
In floods of tears she cried
"All hope's lost it can't be undone
They're wasted and gone" - about the two trees of valinor poisened and dead.
"Save me your speeches
I know (They blinded us all)
What you want
You will take it away from me
Take it and I know for sure
The light she once brought in
Is gone forevermore" - feanor refusing to give the silmarils to the valar as they were the only three things that contained the pure light of the two trees once recovered from Morgoth. And he justifies himself in these lines - "Vala he is that's what you said
Then your oath's been sworn in vain
(But) freely you came and
You freely shall depart
(So) never trust the northern winds
Never turn your back on friends" - the Valar
"Oh I'm heir of the high lord!"
"You better don't trust him"
The enemy of mine
Isn't he of your kind and
Finally you may follow me
Farewell
He said - Feanor
I agree with everything you just said in addition to that there is also what I figure to be Feanor's justification of returning to middle earth with the host of Noldor in the following lines he is speaking to the Valar - "No sign of life did flicker In floods of tears she cried "All hope's lost it can't be undone They're wasted and gone" - about the two trees of valinor poisened and dead.
"Save me your speeches I know (They blinded us all) What you want You will take it away from me Take it and I know for sure The light she once brought in Is gone forevermore" - feanor refusing to give the silmarils to the valar as they were the only three things that contained the pure light of the two trees once recovered from Morgoth. And he justifies himself in these lines - "Vala he is that's what you said Then your oath's been sworn in vain (But) freely you came and You freely shall depart (So) never trust the northern winds Never turn your back on friends" - the Valar
"Oh I'm heir of the high lord!" "You better don't trust him" The enemy of mine Isn't he of your kind and Finally you may follow me Farewell He said - Feanor
@Stronghold Makes me want to cry, thinking of the beauty, majesty and tragedy that is Feanor's tale......
@Stronghold Makes me want to cry, thinking of the beauty, majesty and tragedy that is Feanor's tale......
@Stronghold I mean is it is so passionate, Feanor was no joke.
@Stronghold I mean is it is so passionate, Feanor was no joke.