I disagree completely.
This version is not very singable.
Oasis made it in a much catchier way, with more feeling behind it.
That being said, when I heard this version I was blown away.
Not by the singer or the way it was sung (like i said, it lacked the emotion that oasis uses, and to me emotion is the most important part of how the song is sung) but the arrangemenet and interpretation. The music that goes along with the melody is unreal. It let me ignore the lack of emotion and singability in the voice. It was the music which made this...
I disagree completely.
This version is not very singable.
Oasis made it in a much catchier way, with more feeling behind it.
That being said, when I heard this version I was blown away.
Not by the singer or the way it was sung (like i said, it lacked the emotion that oasis uses, and to me emotion is the most important part of how the song is sung) but the arrangemenet and interpretation. The music that goes along with the melody is unreal. It let me ignore the lack of emotion and singability in the voice. It was the music which made this cover great.
I'm not trying to diss Cartel or anything so don't start screaming that I'm stupid and I don't know what I'm talking about. I'm completely objective on music. Sometimes covers ARE better than the original, and I'll admit it. But this one isn't. Sorry.
It was great though. Don't get me wrong
im gonna have to agree with austin 77....i think this cover is better than when Oasis did it. Cartel is insanely good.
I disagree completely. This version is not very singable. Oasis made it in a much catchier way, with more feeling behind it. That being said, when I heard this version I was blown away. Not by the singer or the way it was sung (like i said, it lacked the emotion that oasis uses, and to me emotion is the most important part of how the song is sung) but the arrangemenet and interpretation. The music that goes along with the melody is unreal. It let me ignore the lack of emotion and singability in the voice. It was the music which made this...
I disagree completely. This version is not very singable. Oasis made it in a much catchier way, with more feeling behind it. That being said, when I heard this version I was blown away. Not by the singer or the way it was sung (like i said, it lacked the emotion that oasis uses, and to me emotion is the most important part of how the song is sung) but the arrangemenet and interpretation. The music that goes along with the melody is unreal. It let me ignore the lack of emotion and singability in the voice. It was the music which made this cover great. I'm not trying to diss Cartel or anything so don't start screaming that I'm stupid and I don't know what I'm talking about. I'm completely objective on music. Sometimes covers ARE better than the original, and I'll admit it. But this one isn't. Sorry. It was great though. Don't get me wrong
Ignore my previous comment. I was thinking of a completely different version. My bad. Sorry.
Ignore my previous comment. I was thinking of a completely different version. My bad. Sorry.