Lyric discussion by sin mi cara 

Cover art for Always and Never lyrics by Coheed and Cambria

I'm confused by GoodApolloImSteve's take on this song. Why would Jesse ask The Writer if he will catch Erica? Jesse doesn't even know that The Writer exists (well, he knows there is a "god" but not that it's just someone writing a story) and he doesn't know about Erica either. Jesse, as well as Claudio, Newo, Ambelina, Mayo, Chase, Josephine, and Patrick (just to name a few) are all characters in the story being written. None of them even know of the Writer's existence until Claudio discovers the mirror and bleeds the two worlds temporarily into one during The Willing Well I.