Of all three versions, I think Weezer's acoustic is by far the best. The electric I'm a little indecisive on. I love Dashboard, really, I do, but I think he made some mistakes on this one - like, as scheisse said, the female background vocals. He does some neat emo sounding stuff (in my opinion, although I guess if you hate Dashboard you're probably repulsed by it), but it bothers me that he changes the ending. I heard his version first, so I thought is was just supposed to end on "It hurts me so much." When I finally got around to hearing Weezer's, I practically cried. Rivers' "I love you so much" is probably the cutest thing I've ever heard. I also adore the simplicity of the breakdown: "I am yours. You are mine. Show me where and I will sign."
Of all three versions, I think Weezer's acoustic is by far the best. The electric I'm a little indecisive on. I love Dashboard, really, I do, but I think he made some mistakes on this one - like, as scheisse said, the female background vocals. He does some neat emo sounding stuff (in my opinion, although I guess if you hate Dashboard you're probably repulsed by it), but it bothers me that he changes the ending. I heard his version first, so I thought is was just supposed to end on "It hurts me so much." When I finally got around to hearing Weezer's, I practically cried. Rivers' "I love you so much" is probably the cutest thing I've ever heard. I also adore the simplicity of the breakdown: "I am yours. You are mine. Show me where and I will sign."