I always thought this was about a gay couple at a club or maybe at home and they are arguing about a girl that one was seen dancing with. There's some hints of allegation, but the one is trying convince John that he didn't do anything with her and that they were only dancing. So the accuser is pretty cynical ("You're everyone that ever cared").
I always thought this was about a gay couple at a club or maybe at home and they are arguing about a girl that one was seen dancing with. There's some hints of allegation, but the one is trying convince John that he didn't do anything with her and that they were only dancing. So the accuser is pretty cynical ("You're everyone that ever cared").