Masters of War

This song absolutely blew me away with the power of the lyrics especially with Eddie Vedder's voice when he performed it at Bob Dylan's 30th anniversary tribute concert. It could be used to analyse any war but I think it was mainly written as a protest to conscription. The lyrics remind me especially of World War 1 where the Generals (especially in the British Army) were miles behind the lines living in luxurious mansions in France and sending their conscripts to their death remorselessly. A generation of youth had no choice but to charge enemy lines in pursuit of heroism, honour, adventure and glory only to be gunned down and buried in the mud. What right did they have to oppose these suicide bayonet charge tactics...what would they know they were young and unlearned.

Or is this song written about Vietnam and the corruption of the US Generals and CIA in Indochina. Conscription was again brought in for this pointless war.

The lyrics are so good they have stood the test of time...they remind me of Iraq an invasion justified by George Bush by illusive "weapons of mass destruction" based on evidence from some CIA fabricated telephone conversations and a few Satellite photographs of trucks carrying barrels.

I was going to post my favorite part of this song, but then I realized that I'd basically just be copying the entire thing. Most songs have one or two parts that really stand out. Not this one. The whole thing is the zenith. Not one lackluster word in the whole thing.

eat shit george bush

I have a few things to say, firstly about this song. This song is one of the most timeless, masterfully wrote songs ever. War has been around since year zero and will always be a horrible, inexcusable way to sort out whatever problems one set of people have with another, Masters of War is timeless, it transcends all time because war is always disguisting and brutal. This song talks about those who instigate these wars, the fuckers that sit behind desks and sign away lives like these people exist in their bank accounts as currency to spend to buy what they want in another country or place, your oil shall cost 100,000 lives, yes they can live with that. We can all sit here and accept war as having a natural place in society, or we can actually do something about it, Bob Dylan tried to educate with this song, but it is up to us to act on the emotions that songs like these bring out in us all, not to just sit back and accept but to be proactive. Secondly, a lot of posts here treat Bob Dylan like he is some sort of songwriting god and genius and that there is not anyone like him today, well, there is. There is hundreds of people who write songs just like this, write poems just like this, write long discourses just like this, just as good as this, but they will never be allowed to be heard outside indie/cult circle, record industry, governments and those big business who have billions of dollars invested in the killing and destruction of people will not allowed another 1960's counterculture to occur. They permiate the airwaves with mind numbing crass, callow, meaningless crap, and people buy it up, eat it up like its the best thing since potatoes. Another thing, just because someone is young doesn't mean that they are not mature or wise or have ideas or think more intelligently than older people, this sort of thing, "oh hes 21 yet writing songs like this" all stems from very old fashoned values that young people should be seen and not heard and that their opinions are not of value, but it is true that a lot of young people are titheads, but we shouldn't really be surprised when one turns out to be a genius when it comes to expression him or her self.

Brian

This song is completely unbelievable. He wrote it when he was 21. Where he got that kind of wisdom I can't even begin to understand. In the liner notes of The Freewheeling Bob Dylan, the album this song is on, it says, "'I've never really written anything like that before,' [Dylan] recalls. 'I don't sing songs which hope people will die, but I couldn't help it in this one. The song is sort of a striking out, a reaction to the last straw, a feeling of what CAN you do?' The rage (which is as much anguish as it is anger) is a way of catharsis, a way of getting temporary relief from the heavy feeling of impotence that affects many who cannot understand a civilization which juggles its own means for oblivion and calls that performance an act toward peace."
I find this song so wise and so totally relevant to the days we're living in; it addresses every aspect of what's wrong with this culture. As is implied in the liner notes, I don't think even Dylan thought that Jesus wouldn't forgive these acts, but - it's difficult to imagine. My favourite line is "you that never done nothing but build to destroy/you play with my world like it's your little toy." The arrogance of all those in power in the world - the wealthy - is so mind-boggling. Not only can they destroy the lives of everyone under them just so they can buy a new yacht, their hubris is so great they think they can outwit death. - He says it all, I'm just babbling, there's nothing I can add to this song.

This song was written in 1963. Before the Vietnam war really started. To say this song is just about Vietnam denies it some of its power. Dylan wrote this song about a timeless event, the rich sending the poor and young off to die and making a profit from war.

So when did music go from completely cool protest singer/songwriter types (like Bob Dylan) who oppose war and champion civil rights, to lyricists who persecute innocent civilians in the name of "art"?

When did it become all about greedy warmongers?

omg guys this song is clearly about drugs!!!!!!!!

jk, Bob Dylan is great. Peace.

Geez Louise this is a cracker of a song. Cant understand some one can put the words together like he has--especially at the age of 21--best line "you fasten all the triggers for the others to fire" and doesnt it just explain war in a nut shell--if perhaps more people listened and thought about idea like this the government wouldn't have pawns to use to be able to achieve stuff like war-the irony of it usually being to gain power-them being the ones with the power and using Us(the people with no power) in order to get more of it. Any hoo its a great song =0)

If songs like this were being written today, Bush might find it more difficult to invade countries without reason...