sort form Submissions:
submissions
Ben Gibbard – Carolina Lyrics 11 years ago
I really like the idea of it being from the perspective of a teenager leaving home, with parents in an abusive relationship. I feel like it makes the most sense.

submissions
The Decemberists – We Both Go Down Together Lyrics 12 years ago
Well, If this really is a prequel to LAL, then maybe the couple didn't die. In the beginning, the lyrics say "Here on these cliffs of Dover
So high you can't see over
And while your head is spinning
Hold tight, it's just beginning"
Maybe those words just mean that they are both so in love that they get that weird butterfly-in-your-stomach feeling.
"We fall, but our souls our flying"
They fall in love, they fall in embrace, ect.
If they didn't die, then the only lyric that confuses me is "You wept, but your soul was willing". It wouldn't make sense.

Now, lets say that they do both die. Then, the lyrics:
"Here on these cliffs of Dover
So high you can't see over
And while your head is spinning
Hold tight, it's just beginning"
is them, holding hands, looking over the edge, thinking their final thoughts before they leap.
"You wept, but your soul was willing"
Miranda didn't want to die, who does? But she is willing to do it, for the sake of love.
"We fell, but our souls were flying"
They are literally falling of the cliff at this point. They have accepted their death, and while I'm not saying that they're happy about dying, they're glad that they will get to be together forever.
"We both go down together"
They both jump and plummet to earth together.

If they both did die, AND this is the prequel to LAL, then maybe the "dry ravine" was the ground underneath the cliff. Miranda was pregnant and literally about to give birth when she jumped, and I think maybe she survived a little longer, and was able to push Leslie out. Or Leslie was never actually birthed, but she became a ghost anyway.

Another crazy idea: Miranda and the narrator had a baby together, but, unable to take all the ridicule of their "socially wrong" relationship, killed themselves. The narrator's parents, while they disliked it, took the baby under their wing. The baby grew up to be Leslie's mother, and we all know what happened after that.

* This information can be up to 15 minutes delayed.