Lyric discussion by mothmeetscloth 

Cover art for Judy and the Dream of Horses lyrics by Belle & Sebastian

also, "Judy I don't know you, if you're gonna show me everything" adds further credit to my theory, He is telling her that it is not the way he wants to get to know her, that he cares about her for what she is and not her body, which she has been using to get the attention she needs in her broken life.