Won't you let me meet you at the pool
Maybe Friday I can get tickets for the dance
And I'll take you
Tell him what we said 'bout "Paint It Black"
Rock and roll is here to stay, come inside where it's okay
And I'll shake you
Would you be an outlaw for my love
If it's so, well, let me know, if it's no, well, I can go
I won't make you
I actually disagree with the older man/young girl thing. Everything about the song suggests more of an innocent, middle school crush sort of thing. The title, I think, means that's they're both thirteen. I don't think there's really anything perverse about the lyrics, save possibly one... and I actually think that line was only thrown in there cause it fit the rhyme scheme. But getting tickets for the dance- the school dance I assumed, talking about music... I assumed the outlaw line was more wanting to be like Bonnie and Clyde, which also strikes me as a very middle school romantic fantasy. Plus, as allmusic was so kind to point out, the way the tempo quickens in the third verse, to me, suggests a very thirteen year old kind of nervousness. Plus, as the other guy said, Chilton says on the live CD it was written when he was 13. Though I don't have the CD to confirm this myself.
I was going to post my own comment disagreeing with the paedophilia-related comments, but this one was pretty much spot-on. The only thing I would add is that, yes, Alex does say on the live CD that he wrote it when he was "about 13" but that can't possibly be true since "Paint It, Black" didn't come out until he was 15.
I was going to post my own comment disagreeing with the paedophilia-related comments, but this one was pretty much spot-on. The only thing I would add is that, yes, Alex does say on the live CD that he wrote it when he was "about 13" but that can't possibly be true since "Paint It, Black" didn't come out until he was 15.
That being said, I do believe that Alex wrote the song, or at least the germ of it, when he was a young adolescent, and that this song is not about an older man falling for...
That being said, I do believe that Alex wrote the song, or at least the germ of it, when he was a young adolescent, and that this song is not about an older man falling for a young girl, but rather about two young teenagers in love. That's it. Pure, simple and completely innocent.
Completely agree--this is written in the voice of a thirteen year-old.
Completely agree--this is written in the voice of a thirteen year-old.
no one really addresses the "Paint it Black" reference. "Paint it Black" is a song about a guy whose girlfriend dies and how that sends him into a deep depression. the line "tell him what we said bout 'Paint it Black'" confounded me for a while, but i think i get it now. i can imagine the two adolescents getting really melodramatic about their love and the boy saying that he'd react the same way if the girl died, and that that's how much they mean to each other. while conveying this to the dad via the song might not be the best choice, it shows how simple and naive they are, and it also reemphasizes that they are as in love with music and rock and roll as they are with each other. so amazing.
this brought tears to my eyes in the best way
this brought tears to my eyes in the best way
That makes a lot of sense, I never quite got that, either. Referencing the song title is odd but the singer is referencing it because it is an inside reference that his girls gets.
That makes a lot of sense, I never quite got that, either. Referencing the song title is odd but the singer is referencing it because it is an inside reference that his girls gets.
This probably won't add a lot to the discussion but if the "Paint It Black" mention is a reference to the Rolling Stones song then Chilton couldn't have written it when he was 13--at least not that line--because he was born in 1950 and that song came out in 1966.
where is their any hint of humbert humbert type shit in the lyrics ?
it's a song about innocent, albeit melodramatic teenage love, and that's it.
The elliott smith cover of this is also beautiful.
Personally one of my all time favourite songs. It depicts that nostalgic, totally innocent love of being a young teenager so perfectly. It even sounds magical and nostalgic too. It's simple to understand, and fits perfectly with the descriptions of such simple pleasures of youth. My favourite line is "would you be an outlaw for my love?" - reminds me of something a kid says to a girl to impress her and sound a lil badass and god it's adorable. Then when he says "if it's so well let me know, if it's no well I can go - I won't make you" - always makes me smile. So childish and innocent. Most gorgeous, nostalgic song ever.
sigh..what a great song. I can never remember how it goes when I try to think of it on the spot but it always creeps up on to me in those little unexpected moments. Why am I the first comment on this? :(
just a pure pop song of pure teenage love. has a very nostalgic feeland probably wouldn't sit well with many teenagers of the post-Dawson's Creek age. whatever, though. this is a timeless classic.
Well I'm only fourteen and I'm listening to it now. I love vintage music. Beautiful, innocent song.
Well I'm only fourteen and I'm listening to it now. I love vintage music. Beautiful, innocent song.
The first verse of this song is an amazingly good description of middle-school innocence. Truely wonderful. Alex Chiltin shoud get his due.
This song is so sweet. "Paint it Black" of course is by the Rolling Stones. I can imagine the boy and his girl listening to the song and discussing how meaningful it is. But not on this website. Heh.