14 Meanings
Add Yours
Follow
Share
Q&A

Madder Red Lyrics

Even when my luck is down
I take joy in that our love grows
But if my vices are a burden
Please don't let me off
Cast me from your home

Because lately I've wronged you
And not been on your side, love
Maybe I have been dumb
Please don't ask me why

I turn away just when you want me
And I know that home is where you want me
There's not much for me there

Never gave a thought to an honorable living
Always had sense enough to lie
It's getting hard to keep pretending I'm worth your time

Never gave a thought to an honorable living
Always had sense enough to lie
It's getting hard to keep pretending I'm worth your time

Because lately I've wronged you
And not been on your side, love
Maybe I have been dumb
Please don't ask me why
Please don't ask me why
Please don't ask me why
Please don't ask me
Song Info
Submitted by
axiomatize On Dec 19, 2009
14 Meanings

Add your song meanings, interpretations, facts, memories & more to the community.

Add your thoughts...
Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

Sometimes it's hard to understand why someone loves you so much, especially when you feel like you're always doing the wrong thing or neglecting them. It's hard to say this song is completely literal in that the narrator is necessarily being a bad guy... The perspective is skewed. If he really was dishonorable, what remorse would he feel for wronging his lover? He just doesn't have confidence that he can do better, and feels she (implied gender, not enforced!) would be better off spending her time on someone who was already right for her. Relationships are complex.

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

WHAT IS WITH THE CLIP FOR THIS SONG?! I love it, but I'm mutually terrified by it.

i love the clip too. it made me cry haha

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

"Never gave a thought to an honorable living"

Pls correct. Great song though.

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

This is a song about guilt and cheating.

Most people cannot describe "why" they cheat, but may feel the guilt and shame of it. They do not want to hurt their partner, but they are unhappy and seek pleasure elsewhere. This song accurately describes the emotions of the cheater, at least in this case.

"But if my vices are a burden Please don't let me off Cast me from your home" Here the vice is sex. he is trying to tell his partner he is not worthy of staying in the home.

".. lately I've wronged you And not been on your side, love Maybe I have been dumb Please don't ask me why" This is the admission of cheating, though the cheater does not know or want to answer why.

"I turn away just when you want me And I know that home is where you want me There's not much for me there"

Not getting any sex at home? Perhaps not wanting to get it at home. Perhaps the excitement is gone.

"Never gave a thought to an honorable living Always had sense enough to lie It's getting hard to keep pretending I'm worth your time"

It is hard not to admit his cheating ways.

Song Meaning

I disagree -- I don't think it's necessarily about cheating. My interpretation is that it's more about feeling inadequate in general, and the lyrics are vague enough that the reason for that could really be anything. Yeah the vices could be sex, but they could be a million other things too.

I also don't think it's limited to romantic love -- I think it could be directed toward anyone who loves you in any sense of the word (friends, parents, etc.). The music video supports this idea because it's about a girl and her pet, and this song totally applies...

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

The clip IS weird. But maybe the creature is the guys self imagine after what he is doing (or not doing) to the girl of the clip.

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

fantastic song. i thing it's pretty straightforward - two people in a relationship and the one singing obviously really appreciates their relationship and love (Even when my luck is down, I take joy in that our love grows) but recently this person has not been treating the other as well as they should be, which they realize (Because lately I've wronged you And not been on your side, love Maybe I have been dumb) and they're realizing more and more that the other person deserves better (It's getting hard to keep pretending I'm worth your time) but they're not ready for that yet and don't want to acknowledge it / just keep pretending like everything is fine (Please don't ask me why)

My Interpretation
Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

the lyric is "maybe I've been gone"

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

Well my opinion about the meaning of the video goes like this..

It's singed from a pets perspective. As you can see from the video, in the beginning the "lump" is on top of the bed, just like cats and dogs are.

After that, Kristen is eating breakfest and the "lump" comes into kitchen and wants to eat. Well it can't coz s/he is ill.

After that Kristen goes to somekind of audition, but the lump gets sicker and she has to leave.

She grabs the lump and rushes in to veterinary hospital, notice the dogs as she is inside.

Well the doctors cant save her and the lump dies.

Song Meaning

kuubone, Im pretty sure youre right. I recently read this release about the song:

"Anyone who’s lost a beloved cat or dog can relate to the absurd, heartbreaking new video for Yeasayer’s “Madder Red”. The clip stars Kristen Bell (“Veronica Mars”,Forgetting Sarah Marshall) as a distraught owner of a sick pet. The pet happens to be an amorphous, one-eyed (and oddly lovable!) mass of flesh. It was made by wildly talented Swedish director Andreas Nilsson (Fever Ray, MGMT) and you can check it out below or at Pitchfork.tv."

definitely an interesting song!

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

I think this song is definitely about his drug problem affecting his relationship: But if my vices are a burden (drugs) Please don't let me off (make me get help) Cast me from your home (make me go to rehab dont be an inhibiter) Because lately I've wronged you (maybe ive stolen money or been emotionally vacant or abusive because im withdrawing) And not been on your side, love (cuz ive been doing those things) Maybe I have been dumb (because im weak and addicted) Please don't ask me why (addiction is hard)

This was my favorite off this album. Never really thought about the words until now.

Cover art for Madder Red lyrics by Yeasayer

This song is about Gambling Addiction. The writer of the song confirmed this. The lyric "even when my luck is down" kinda confirms this. And the rest is basically how its effecting their relationship him saying that he shouldn't be forgiven for his failings but please don't ask him why as he clearly can't put into words why he is doing the things he is.

Love this song and a few on the album.

Lyric Correction
 
Questions and Answers

Ask specific questions and get answers to unlock more indepth meanings & facts.

Ask a question...