Who's That Girl?

In my opinion I think this song is about Hilary herself. I think she's talking to her self. She has changed into something she doesnt want to be. When she says "by the way, whos that girl? living my life?" I think shes taking to herself. Like she wants to change into a better person and shes not proud of who she is atm.

simply beautiful.. just like hilary herself

simply beautiful.. just like hilary herself

haha @ broken_inside. But I admit, I like it. Many artists used the yiyiyiyi's in their songs, not just Avril. I think Alanis Morissette has done quite a few of those. All in all, it's a cool song. Well done Hilary.

i not a fan of hilary...but i like this song

i think its stupid my sis likes it but does not know what its about she 13 and she just found out that songs have meanings

this song is great!! shows that hils a human like us all. she gets jealous of other people to even though she appears to have it. and quit dissing her honestly if ya dont like her why you bothered to waste your breath on her?

yes this song is supposed to be who's that girl? she is jealous of this guy who dumped her for another girl..yet when she said I'm not sorry I'm not her she doesnt care..but then she goes on singing about how she is still jealous so shes trying to get over it and blaming the guy for taking that whore but she really cant. she doesnt want him to have that other girl because she made him go through a rollercoaster of emotions..happy&sad&mad&etc. she cant believe that the other girl could bethe one` for him..and that only she should be..all in all, hilary is jealous.

yes this song is supposed to be who's that girl? she is jealous of this guy who dumped her for another girl..yet when she said I'm not sorry I'm not her she doesnt care..but then she goes on singing about how she is still jealous so shes trying to get over it and blaming the guy for taking that whore but she really cant. she doesnt want him to have that other girl because she made him go through a rollercoaster of emotions..happy&sad&mad&etc. she cant believe that the other girl could bethe one` for him..and that only she should be..all in all, hilary is jealous.

I dont think its about a guy.

I had this friend, and she was constantly ditching me for someone more popular. I hated it. Completely hated it. But despite all that, i still hung out with her. And friends are the world, whos that gorl who has stolen my world.

Then i got over it. She was a bitch about it. hypocrite, caus when i started hanging out with someone else, shes like "Your drifting away!" And my other best friend felt the same way to. She said "I have to have SOMEONE to hang out with!" So the bridge was just me giving up. Im not sorry im not her. Cause im not gonna change for you. Get over it.

Shes everywhere i wanna be. Thats the ditching part. She started ditching me to do stuff with this girl, even though she had plans with me. So, thats what i think of this song. I love it, and i think im gonna send it to my "Friend" see what she says.